We’ve broken a lot of rules in putting together My Pizzetta. One of those rules said that successful pizza restaurants offer small, medium, large and sheet pizzas. In creating My Pizzetta we wanted each customer to get what he or she wanted without having to compromise because the pizza would be shared. That’s why our pizzas are individually designed by you and sized accordingly. We offer three sizes: small or 8 inch which is ideal for lunch or for a child’s pizza; medium or 10 inch and large or 12 inch. How much pizza is that really? Well consider that a 10 inch pizza has an area of nearly 100 square inches (94.895 in to be exact). The large has an area of over 113 square inches. Yup, that’s a lot of pizza!! No one will go hungry. As the Italians say… “Great pizza and still room for gelato!"
Dough is the essence of a great pizza. We will only work milled 00 flour. The wheat has a softer consistency when milled to the 00 standard. This General Mills Neapolitan flour is simply the best for making incredible pizza dough. The cost of a bag of 00 flour is considerably higher than that of traditional bakers flour but it will deliver a product better than any of our competitors.
My Pizzetta sauces are all made fresh each day. Unlike some pizza sauces that are simmered for hours and then cooked a second time when they go on the pizza, My Pizzetta pizza sauce is never cooked before it goes in the oven. Each fresh sauce with its distinctive blend of spices is put on your pizza and cooked for the first time in the oven when your pizza is being baked making it very nutritious. The result is an amazingly fresh tasting pizza sauce you and your family will love.
Toppings – Local and Fresh
Over 80% of people who order pizza prefer to choose their own toppings instead of buying a predetermined specialty pizza. Providing choices is what My Pizzetta is all about. When we began searching for distributors for our toppings we set clear criteria. All the food had to be safe, fresh and produced locally. This is not so easy in a Midwest climate! Nonetheless we are able to offer our customers food products that meet those criteria. We encourage you to look at the “Where Our Food Comes From” page and its available links to learn more.
We cook our chicken with our own special blend of Penzey's herbs and spices. This is done daily so you get the freshest chicken possible. We also cook our bacon each day in strips so that when you get your pizza you can see the strips of bacon on your pizza and not just crumbles.
Nothing screams “great pizza” better than the cheese, and we offer four distinct choices,
- For the traditionalist we have our own blend of mozzarella, provolone and muenster cheeses. This is an industry standard because the mozzarella provides that distinct pizza taste; the provolone provides the stretchy texture, while muenster gives it a creamy quality that we love when we eat pizza.
- For those that love bold taste we have a smoked cheese that provides a great backdrop for any topping but we think it really blends well with roasted red peppers, caramelized onions, jalapeno peppers, or old world pepperoni.
- We also offer fresh mozzarella. This is the cheese that is found on pizza all over Italy. It is sliced, not shredded and has a unique quality that provides a traditional pizza experience.
For the real pizza pioneer, we also have cheddar cheese. By using cheddar with ham, bacon, and onions the pizza connoisseur can create a distinctly American style pizza.
Sprinkle It On
Some things were not meant to be cooked on a pizza. That is why we offer toppings that are put on the pizza AFTER it comes out of the oven. This includes our own parmesan/romano grated cheese blend, hot red pepper flakes, fresh basil leaves, an dried herb blend, feta cheese and a drizzle of barbecue sauce. Most after-bake toppings are free.
Your pizza will have some charring that is caused when the gas in the dough is driven out by the intense heat of the oven. Your pizza should not have a burnt taste. The Char is characteristic of cooking your pizza very quickly in an 800 degree oven. This is how Italians have been cooking their pizza for thousands of years. You can find pizza ovens like ours at the site of Pompeii going back 2000 years. So embrace the Char.
A good salad is hard to find. Is there anything more disappointing than ordering a dinner salad and this sad old lettuce comes to the table with even sadder slices of two cucumber slices, and 4 dried croutons? When available we purchase locally grown, lettuce and vegetables for our salads.
Yes it is more expensive for us, but you are worth it and so is your family. For our little ones we are offering veggies and dippies. These will also have fresh cut carrots, not milled carrots that are made to look like little carrots, cucumber and celery. Our salad dressings will be an offering of freshly made and Neuman’s Own. Our house dressing is a honey balsamic you will love.
Don’t forget dessert…ever! With My Pizzetta you will have room for dessert and you will want it!
We also offer cookies when available. The dough comes from Main Street Gourmet in Cuyahoga Falls (another local connection). We have chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, peanut butter and white chocolate-macadamia nut.
Are you a Coke person? Do you like root beer? Sprite? Dr. Pepper? How about ice tea – sweetened or non-sweetened? Maybe just bottled water? My Pizzetta wants to offer you what you like. We have fountain drinks that include coke, diet coke, sprite, root beer, Dr. Pepper and lemonade. We also have bottled water and Snapple Peach Ice Tea in bottles.
After 40 years each for the owners in education (80 years YIKES!) we are very concerned about the food provided to our youngest patrons. We will provide a healthy meal that we would feel good about serving to our children and grandchildren. A kids meal consists of an 8” pizza with one topping, drink (we recommend Honest Kids juice pouch) veggies and dippies or small salad.